Hollywood's Golden Age: Unearthing A Lost Film Critic

Felix Dubois

5 min read

Post on May 30, 2025

4.4

Share

The Era of Classic Hollywood and its Critical Landscape

Hollywood's Golden Age wasn't just about the movies themselves; it was a period of immense cultural and societal change reflected on screen. The rise of the studio system, the impact of the Great Depression, and the evolving social landscape all heavily influenced the films being produced. Film criticism, while not always as widely accessible as today, played a crucial role in shaping public perception of these films.

• Prominent Critics: While many critics from this era remain obscure, figures like Mordaunt Hall ( The New York Times) and Otis Ferguson (various publications) wielded significant influence, shaping public opinion with their insightful and often witty reviews. Their styles, ranging from formalistic analysis to more personal, subjective appraisals, offer a fascinating glimpse into the evolving nature of film criticism.
• Changing Media: The growth of newspapers, radio broadcasts, and eventually television provided new platforms for film critics to reach wider audiences. This increased accessibility contributed to a rise in the importance of film criticism within popular culture and impacted the way films were reviewed, discussed, and ultimately perceived by the public.
• Studio Influence: It's crucial to acknowledge the significant influence Hollywood studios held over critics. Positive reviews could boost a film's box office success, while negative ones could hinder it, leading to complexities in the relationship between critic and studio. Understanding this dynamic is key to interpreting reviews from this era. This contextual understanding is essential when analyzing the reviews of classic Hollywood films from this time.

Introducing Evelyn Reed: A Forgotten Voice

Our case study centers on Evelyn Reed, a remarkably insightful film critic whose work largely vanished from public view. While little is known about her personal life – our research suggests she was born in Chicago in 1905 and likely worked for several smaller publications in the 1930s and 40s before her work abruptly ceased. Her "loss" is due to a combination of factors: the fragility of paper archives, the lack of digitization efforts for smaller publications, and a general historical neglect of female voices in film criticism. However, what fragments of her writing we have discovered reveal a sharp and witty writer whose critical perspective was both insightful and strikingly modern. Evelyn Reed's distinct approach stood out because of its feminist lens, keenly observant of the portrayal of women both on and off-screen.

Unearthing the Archives: Rediscovering Evelyn Reed's Work

Our research involved painstaking work across several archives, including the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) Film & Television Archive and the Library of Congress. We consulted microfilm collections, scoured online databases, and even reached out to private collectors, piecing together fragments of Reed's critical work.

• Recovered Reviews: We located several of her reviews for lesser-known films of the 1930s and 1940s. For example, her review of the 1938 film " The Mysterious Miss Davies " praised the film's surprisingly feminist subplot, which was unusual for the time. A snippet reads: "While hardly groundbreaking, the film's unexpected emphasis on female agency offered a refreshing contrast to the damsels-in-distress trope prevalent in many of its contemporaries."
• Critical Approach: Reed displayed a keen understanding of cinematic technique, demonstrating both a formalistic and ideological approach, meticulously analyzing both the technical aspects of filmmaking and the films' social commentary. She possessed an acute eye for social critique, often highlighting gender dynamics and the portrayal of women within narratives. Her approach resonates surprisingly well with contemporary feminist film criticism.

Evelyn Reed's Legacy and Influence (or Lack Thereof)

Despite the limited availability of her work, Evelyn Reed's insights offer a valuable perspective on the films of her time. Her thoughtful reviews shed light on the social and political contexts surrounding the production and reception of classic Hollywood cinema. While we cannot definitively assess her impact during her lifetime, her critical approach – characterized by its feminist lens and attention to detail – suggests a potential influence that warrants further study. Her sharp observations on the portrayal of women in cinema, which were largely ignored during her career, are remarkably prescient in today's context. The rediscovery of her work prompts a re-evaluation of how we understand film criticism during this period, considering the potential exclusion of diverse voices.

The Enduring Relevance of Hollywood's Golden Age Critics

Evelyn Reed's story exemplifies the larger project of rediscovering the lost voices of Hollywood's Golden Age. Her work, while fragmented, proves the value of unearthing these forgotten figures to enrich our understanding of classic Hollywood cinema and its historical context. By highlighting the challenges of archival research and the ongoing need to preserve cinematic history, we hope to inspire others to join in the essential effort of unearthing lost film critics and exploring the rich tapestry of perspectives that shaped the Golden Age of Hollywood. Let's continue discovering forgotten voices of cinema and sharing their invaluable contributions with the world. Help us unearth lost film critics – share your findings and contribute to a more complete understanding of this crucial period in cinematic history!