Are School Suspensions Doing More Harm Than Good? A Critical Analysis

Felix Dubois

6 min read

Post on May 02, 2025

4.0

Share

The Negative Impacts of School Suspensions on Student Outcomes

School suspensions, while seemingly a straightforward disciplinary measure, often carry significant negative consequences for students' academic progress, mental health, and future prospects. Let's delve into the detrimental effects.

Increased Risk of Academic Failure

Suspensions directly disrupt a student's education, leading to a cascade of negative academic outcomes.

• Higher dropout rates: Students who are frequently suspended are significantly more likely to drop out of school.
• Lower test scores: Missing instruction time due to suspension negatively impacts academic performance and test scores.
• Reduced graduation rates: The cumulative effect of missed classes and academic setbacks increases the likelihood of not graduating.
• Difficulty catching up on missed coursework: The work missed during suspension can be difficult to make up, leading to further academic struggles.

Studies consistently demonstrate a strong correlation between school suspension and decreased academic performance. For example, a study published in the Journal of Educational Psychology found that students suspended even once were more likely to experience significant learning gaps and lower standardized test scores compared to their peers. These statistics highlight the urgent need to reconsider the efficacy of suspensions as a primary disciplinary tool. Understanding the consequences of school suspension on academic achievement is vital for developing more effective strategies.

Mental Health and Behavioral Issues

The experience of suspension can have profound and lasting negative impacts on a student's mental health and behavior.

• Increased risk of depression: Suspension can lead to feelings of isolation, shame, and hopelessness, increasing the risk of depression and anxiety.
• Increased anxiety: The fear of further suspension can create chronic anxiety and stress.
• Substance abuse: Students facing suspension may turn to drugs or alcohol as coping mechanisms.
• Involvement in criminal activity: Suspension can disrupt the protective structure of school and increase the likelihood of involvement in criminal activity.

The stigmatization associated with suspension can further exacerbate these problems. Students may feel ostracized by their peers and develop a negative self-image, leading to a cycle of behavioral problems. The long-term effects of school suspension on mental health necessitate a shift toward more supportive and holistic disciplinary approaches. Addressing school suspension effects on student mental health is crucial for creating a positive and nurturing learning environment.

The School-to-Prison Pipeline

Perhaps the most troubling consequence of school suspensions is their contribution to the school-to-prison pipeline.

• Disproportionate suspension rates for minority students: Studies consistently show that minority students, particularly Black and Hispanic students, are suspended at disproportionately higher rates than their white peers, even when controlling for other factors.
• Perpetuation of systemic inequalities: These disparities reinforce existing inequalities and perpetuate cycles of disadvantage.
• Increased likelihood of future incarceration: Repeated suspensions can lead to a pattern of negative interactions with the justice system, increasing the risk of future incarceration.

The overuse of suspension contributes significantly to racial disparities in education and the criminal justice system. Examining school suspension statistics reveals a deeply troubling pattern that demands immediate attention and systemic reform. Addressing this inequity requires a multifaceted approach that tackles both school discipline and broader societal issues of racial injustice. Promoting equity in education is paramount in breaking the cycle of school suspension and incarceration.

Alternative Disciplinary Approaches and Their Effectiveness

Fortunately, there are numerous alternative disciplinary approaches that offer more positive and effective outcomes than suspensions.

Restorative Justice Practices

Restorative justice focuses on repairing harm caused by wrongdoing and involves all parties in a collaborative process of conflict resolution.

• Focus on repairing harm: The emphasis is on addressing the impact of the behavior on others and finding ways to make amends.
• Involving all parties in conflict resolution: Students, teachers, and parents are actively involved in finding solutions that meet the needs of all stakeholders.
• Promoting empathy and accountability: Restorative practices aim to foster empathy and understanding while holding students accountable for their actions.

Restorative justice methods prioritize positive relationships and create a more collaborative school environment. This approach has been shown to reduce suspension rates and improve school climate. Implementing restorative justice is a proven strategy for effective school discipline that promotes positive outcomes.

Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports (PBIS)

PBIS is a proactive, data-driven approach to improving student behavior and school climate.

• Proactive approach focusing on prevention: PBIS aims to prevent misbehavior through clear expectations, positive reinforcement, and proactive interventions.
• Teaching positive behaviors: Students are taught specific social-emotional skills and positive behavioral strategies.
• Creating a supportive school climate: PBIS creates a positive and inclusive school environment that fosters student engagement and reduces the need for disciplinary measures.

Implementing a comprehensive PBIS framework can significantly reduce the reliance on suspensions, promoting a healthier school environment. The benefits of PBIS are well documented and show its potential as a crucial tool for effective school discipline.

Counseling and Mental Health Services

Addressing underlying mental health issues can significantly reduce disruptive behaviors and improve student outcomes.

• Addressing underlying mental health issues contributing to disruptive behavior: Many behavioral problems stem from undiagnosed or untreated mental health issues.
• Providing students with support and resources: Access to counseling and mental health services provides students with the support they need to manage their emotions and behavior.

Integrating mental health services into schools is crucial for creating a comprehensive approach to student well-being and reducing reliance on punitive disciplinary measures. Investing in student mental health is an investment in the future of our students and schools. Social-emotional learning programs are also key components in this approach to promoting behavioral health.

Conclusion: Re-evaluating School Suspensions – A Call for Change

The evidence presented clearly demonstrates that school suspensions have far-reaching negative consequences for students' academic success, mental health, and future prospects, disproportionately impacting minority students. Are school suspensions doing more harm than good? The answer, based on this analysis, is a resounding yes. Instead of relying on suspensions as a primary disciplinary strategy, schools should embrace alternative approaches like restorative justice, PBIS, and increased access to mental health services. These methods offer more effective and equitable solutions that promote student well-being and create positive school climates. Let's work together to replace ineffective school suspensions with more supportive and effective disciplinary practices that benefit all students. We need school suspension reform that prioritizes student success and equity. Let's advocate for alternative discipline strategies and build a more just and supportive educational system for all.